Quality Mattress Protectors: Reviews and Buyers Guide

For someone who has 4 children, it should be a no brainer that all of the mattresses in my house need to be protected. My children like to break the rules and most of the time, it’s the “no drinks in your bedroom” rule. It came to the point where I had to buy all new ones and protectors to go with them.

Take it from me, if you want to keep it in “like new” shape for a long time and protect them from potty training accidents, leak through diapers, spills, and other mishaps, you need to find yourself the best mattress protector you possibly can.

If you're looking for something with bed bug protection, we  recommend a mattress encasement.

Best Mattress Protector Comparisons

Brand

Details

Our Rating

Luna

  • Hypoallergenic
  • 1 lb
  • 10-year warranty
  • $$$

SureGuard

  • Hypoallergenic
  • 1 lb
  • 30-day full refund
  • $$$

SafeRest

  • Hypoallergenic
  • 1 lb
  • 10-year warranty
  • $$

Hanna Kay

  • Hypoallergenic
  • 1 lb
  • 10-year warranty
  • $

Priva

  • Hypoallergenic
  • 1 lb
  • 30-day guarantee
  • $

There is a Difference

Before we begin, you should know that a mattress pad and cover are not the same thing. I have talked to a lot of people in the past, especially moms like myself, who got confused about the difference between a cover and a pad. When they went out and bought something that they thought was going to protect their mattress they ended up texting me and asking why when their kids had accidents the pad wasn’t helping to protect the bed. Well, the answer is simple, there is a difference between the two. One protects the bed and the other acts as a topper for your bed, with no protection.

A Pad Isn't The Same

A mattress pad is not the same thing as a protector or cover. Many people think that because you buy a mattress pad, it is going to do the same thing as a cover. The truth is that the pad is more for adding temperature regulation, or heating and a topper for comfort,  not protection. If you have an accident or sweat at night, that moisture is still going to go into the pad and you will end up having to throw it away or buy a new one over time.

A cover or protector is specifically meant to protect your mattress from accidents, spills, moisture and more. You can take the cover off to wash and your mattress will still look like new. If you are looking for something that is going to protect your bed, a cover or protector is what you want, not a pad.

How Do They Protect

When you think of a mattress protector, do you automatically think that they are to help prevent pee accidents? If you do, you shouldn’t, and here is why. Yes, they do work wonders with pee if you have children or bladder control issues, but if you don’t have kids prone to wetting the bed, there are still other things that you need to protect your mattress from such as dust mites, moisture, spills and more

Keeping It Clean

Over time, mattresses absorb dead skin, dust mites, oil, and moisture. Ohio State University published materials saying “A typical used mattress may have 100,000 to 10-million mites inside”. If you are anything like me, you may be starting to itch yourself just thinking about it.

You can prevent this from happening by finding the best mattress protector for your bed, especially if you suffer from a dust mite allergy. Dust mites feed on the dead skin we shed as we sleep. If you take the protector off and wash it, the dust mites will have nothing to feast on. You may also see a drop in how often your dust mite allergies act up. You may find yourself sneezing and wheezing less, having a less frequent runny nose and no more shortness of breath as you sleep.

Keep It "Like New"

There is nothing quite as satisfying as sleeping on a brand new mattress. You can keep your mattress feeling like new with a waterproof protector. Any kind of moisture from bedwetting or spills will wear down the fibers of your mattress, thus, shortening its comfort life. If moisture keeps reaching your bed, over time it will shorten its life and you will end up having to replace it more quickly if it isn’t protected.

Types of Mattress Protectors

If you want to find the best mattress cover or protector, you need to know what kinds there are to choose from to best suit your needs. Not all mattress protectors are the same. Some are hypoallergenic (anti-allergy), specifically for dust mite allergies and waterproof.

The Cheap Route

If you are looking for something that isn’t going to break your bank and something that is just good enough to protect your mattress, you will end up with something that feels similar to plastic. This is something that would possibly be on a kids bed. These types of protectors will be less breathable, less durable and quite possibly more noisy than others. I use these on my kids beds. The noise doesn’t bother them and they are just good enough to get the job done. Their mattress is still being protected and if anything happens and I need to buy a new one, I won’t have to spend a lot.

A Little Better

The next step up from cheap is “a little better”. These protectors are usually waterproof and breathable. These are a little higher prices, but they will work better than the plastic covers that can make a lot of noise and work at just the bare minimum. These covers will help to protect against minor spills and moisture while protecting the life of the mattress it is covering.

The Best

The best type of protectors you can get for your mattress(es) is one that has some kind of performance fabric on the top. This fabric will help to wick away heat and moisture from the body. These can usually withstand more moisture than the other types of covers, but these ones are more expensive than most. If you are the type of person who sweats a lot in their sleep, like my husband, then this is the route you may want to consider. My husband is a night sweater and let me tell you something, I wish I had a protector on my bed like the kids do because my mattress is starting to smell a little funky.

Top 5 Mattress Protector Reviews

Luna Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector-Queen

Overview

  • 10-year warranty
  • 12 x 3.5 x 12 inches
  • 1 pound
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof
  • Machine Washable

No matter what size you need to protect, the Luna premium hypoallergenic 100% waterproof mattress protector has you covered. This protector comes in 7 sizes to fit any size you have which is nice because if you have a certain size bed that is uncommon, like the California King, you will still have the option to buy a cover. This protects against allergens, dust mites, bacteria, perspiration, fluids, and the occasional bedwetting accident due to incontinence or potty training toddlers.

If you are worried about it retaining heat, don’t. This protector is 100% waterproof and equipped with Luna airflow technology which allows air to circulate through it while repelling spills. If at any time you need to wash your protector, just take it off and toss it in the washing machine. It is suggested that you wash it quarterly for best results.

One of the other features that makes this protector a great buy is that it is hypoallergenic. The hypoallergenic cotton terry surface is great for eczema, asthma, and allergy sufferers. Dust mites are known to cause eczema and if you have a protector on your mattress to keep dust mites away, it can also help to keep the eczema away as well, or at least under control. By ridding your mattress of allergens, it will drastically reduce the effects of your allergies so you can sleep better at night.

Pros

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof
  • 10-year warranty
  • Noiseless
  • Quality construction
  • Good fit
  • Breathes
  • USA made
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Make some people too warm
  • Did not protect against bed wetting

SureGuard Mattress Protector - 100% Waterproof, Hypoallergenic

Overview

  • 10-full replacement warranty/30-day risk free/full refund
  • 54 x 75 x 17 inches
  • 1 pound
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof
  • Machine washable

The SureGuard 100% waterproof and hypoallergenic mattress protector is surely a great fit for any size bed, including a crib. It offers top protection against bed wetting accidents, liquids, stains, and perspiration. This type of protector is perfect for children who are transitioning to a new bed, starting to potty train, or those who are frequent bed wetters, whatever the situation. If you are looking to protect the warranty of your or your childs mattress, this is the way to do it.

Since this protector is hypoallergenic, it helps to block dust mites, bacteria, allergens, mildew, and mold for great allergy relief. If you are an allergy sufferer, you will notice a change with this protector on your mattress. Not only is it hypoallergenic, but it is also noiseless, wicks away moisture, retains the natural feel of your mattress and is free from fire retardants, Phthalates, PVC, Vinyl, and other toxic chemicals.

Unlike some protectors, this one is easy to clean and durable, which is a nice feature because it doesn’t have to be thrown away after it is soiled. It is recommended that if you are using it on a bed that is prone to frequent accidents, use two protectors. If you are looking for six-sided protection, purchasing the SureGuard mattress protector is recommended for best results.

Pros

  • Allergy relief
  • Breathable
  • Machine washable
  • Quiet
  • Comfortable
  • Affordable
  • True fit

Cons

  • Chemical smell
  • Some claim not liquid proof
  • Doesn’t breathe well

SafeRest Premium Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress Protector-Queen

Overview

  • 10-year product warranty
  • 1 pound
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof
  • Machine washable

The SafeRest premium hypoallergenic and waterproof mattress protector is there for you to protect against dust mites, fluids, perspiration, bed wetting, allergens and bacteria. This is one of the best mattress covers for dust mite allergies or for those that have allergy symptoms. It is also a great solution for those who have children, pets, asthma, eczema, and incontinence. No matter what size bed you have, this protector has you covered with 6 sizes to choose from.

This hypoallergenic protector has a cotton terry surface with a membrane back coating that makes it noise proof, waterproof, and breathable. Once you place this on your mattress, you will not notice a difference in the feel or sound of it. You will be able to sleep comfortably without having to listen to the crinkle noise of PVC-type protectors. I appreciate this feature because I am a light sleeper and I definitely would not want to listen to crinkling as I toss and turn at night.

This protector is a fitted sheet style meaning that it is installed like a fitted sheet would be. This is a great feature because you won’t have to worry about the protector moving around as you move in your sleep. The elastic band ensures a perfect and stable fit and you can pull excess material under the mattress to avoid bunching. If anything does happen to it and you need to wash it, you can throw it in the washing machine with regular detergent that do not contain bleach.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Aids in allergy relief
  • Odorless
  • Comfortable
  • Affordable
  • Easy to install
  • Easy to wash
  • Noiseless

Cons

  • Doesn’t cover whole mattress
  • No padding
  • Some claim not waterproof
  • Made some overheat

Hanna Kay Premium 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector Hypoallergenic

Overview

  • 10-year warranty
  • 1 pound
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof
  • Machine washable

The Hanna Kay premium 100% waterproof and hypoallergenic mattress protector is a fitted sheet style protector that can fit all depths from 6” to 22” in one of 4 sizes. These sizes include twin, full, queen, and king. This protector has a cotton terry style surface and will not change the feel of your mattress once it is installed.

This protector can help to protect your mattress against liquid stains, bacteria, dust mites, and allergens. If you suffer from dust mite allergies or just regular allergies, this will help to deter the symptoms while you are sleeping. While you are sleeping, your body perspires and sheds skin cells that dust mites feed on. All of the bacteria, mold, and fungus that accumulates can penetrate your mattress and make allergies worse. Dust mites are also known to cause eczema and if your protector can protect against dust mites, it can help reduce eczema as well. It is also ideal for those who may suffer from incontinence and asthma.

This protector is also breathable thanks to microscopic holes in the membrane layer. These holes allow the it to circulate air while protecting against moisture and liquids. Your body can stay at a comfortable temperature while you are asleep.

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Waterproof
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Aids in allergy relief
  • Noiseless
  • Fits like a fitted sheet
  • Good quality
  • Affordable
  • True fit

Cons

  • Some claim not waterproof
  • Made bed warm
  • Some claim it’s noisy

Priva High Quality Ultra Waterproof Sheet Protector

Overview

  • 30-day return
  • 11.6 x 8.8 x 3 inches
  • 1 pound
  • Waterproof
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Machine washable

Most mattress protectors are waterproof and great for a lot of different things. This particular protector is ideal for children and those with adult incontinence. The Priva high quality waterproof sheet protector comes in 10 different sizes to fit all different size beds. It is generously oversized and meant for maximum protection by quickly absorbing liquids and locking up to 8 cups of moisture.

This protector has four layers of protection that include a soft quilted cotton and polyester surface, a soft polyester fiberfill layer, super absorbent high density inner layer, and a vinyl waterproof non slip barrier. These four layers provide the best protection against bed wetting, spills, moisture, perspiration and more by resting on top of the sheet to protect the mattress from staining and possibly voiding the warranty. This would have been helpful when my oldest son was on diuretics and frequently had accidents that his pull-ups couldn’t handle.

You can wash it up to 300 times and it is bleachable for ultimate sanitization. It has also been certified by a third party independent lab claiming to be free of Cadmium, lead, mercury, and all Phthalates. This mattress protector will keep you from having to get up in the middle of the night to strip your bed due to an accident of any kind. This makes it perfect for children who are potty training, transitioning to a bigger bed, for adults who have incontinence issues, pets who are prone to accidents or just for general protection to keep your mattress like new.

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • highly absorbent
  • non-slip backing
  • Washable
  • Bleachable
  • Environmentally friendly
  • Saves money
  • Hospital quality
  • Waterproof
  • Great for potty training
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Some claim it leaks
  • Noisy
  • Vinyl has an odor

Which Is The Best

After careful reviews of these mattress protectors, the best one on the list would have to be the Luna Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector. The reasoning for this is because it will help allergy sufferers sleep at night, keep dust mites away, protect your mattress, and it is discrete. It is also great for potty training toddlers, adults who may sweat at night and protect from pee spots from pets. It does not look like something that would be on a hospital bed, it fits like a sheet and it helps to keep liquid from staining the mattress.

Leave a Comment:

We believe in transparency, so please note we earn a commission on any sales generated through some of the links on our site at no additional cost to you.