Top Mattress Toppers On The Market: Reviews And Buyers Guide

Over time, mattresses just don’t seem as comfortable as they use to. Maybe the springs are starting to come through or it just seems a little on the lumpy side. In this case, you may be considering buying a new mattress, but mattresses are expensive. So, how do you get the feel of a new mattress without actually buying a new mattress? The answer is simple, buy a mattress topper, and not just a regular topper, but the best mattress topper.

Best Mattress Topper Comparisons



Our Ratings


Overfilled Ultra Soft Microplush

Dry Clean Only

6.9 pounds

30-day warranty

Sleep Innovations

4-Inch Dual Layer Quee

Machine washable

23.7 pounds

10-year limited warranty

Exceptional Sheets

Extra Plush Fitted Queen

Machine Washable

8.8 pounds

10-year limited warranty

Memory Foam

Density Visco Elastic Topper

Not washable

28.8 pounds

3-year limited warranty


2-inch Ventilated Memory Foam

Not washable

2.2 pounds

3-year warranty

Why A Mattress Topper?

Mattress toppers are great for those who may not be able to afford a new mattress that is going to suite all of their needs. I can personally say that I am one of those people who went and bought a topper instead of a new mattress.

I have a California King pillow top bed that has been used for over 10 years. I had been putting off buying a new mattress because they are just too expensive for me. One day, my husband and I decided it was time for something else, so we looked into mattress toppers. We decided to go with a memory foam mattress topper because I was very pregnant and the memory foam formed to my belly which made sleeping much more comfortable. We have had the same mattress for 5 years now and I am still sleeping wonderfully on it.

The Benefits of Toppers

Toppers have an array of benefits along with being affordable. “Memory foam made its debut for NASA and after that, it was made in other products such as helmets and shoes.” It even made its way into medicine, being used in prosthetics and as seating pads for those who are disabled to avoid pressure ulcers. As this was happening, memory foam took off and is now helping people sleep better.

Not Too Firm

Mattress toppers can soften a bed that is too firm. You may overall like your mattress, but it may just be a little bit too firm. The pillow top mattress topper helps to take some of the firmness away so that you aren’t constantly tossing and turning all night because your bed is too firm.

Cooler Sleep

Another benefit is that the memory foam toppers have new materials that allow for a cooler sleep, literally. Personally, I love this kind of topper. This is the kind that I have and it really does keep you cool at night if your body temperature is too warm. I have the mattress that has breathable holes that allow air to flow through them, keeping me at a comfortable temperature all night. This would be very beneficial to people who are always warm and can’t seem to cool down while they are sleeping.


They are safe, innovative and a can be used virtually anywhere. If you don’t want to use it on your bed or you are going on vacation and want to bring your bed with you, you can. I only say this because I do it all of the time. When my family goes camping, I use the topper in our pop up camper. If you have ever slept in a pop up, you know that the mattresses are thin and hard as a rock. We bring ours with us and it is like sleeping at home.

Which Type Is the Best?

There are so many different ones out there that you may not know which one you need. Memory foam toppers seem to be at the top of the list in popularity. Unfortunately, it is not as easy as just picking one out and going with it. There are different sizes and thicknesses that you need to think about.

If you are looking for toppers specifically for back pain? click here.


2-inch memory foam toppers are perfect for medium pressure, which means that it is going to be average. If you are a smaller build person, this may be all you need. This is also the least expensive option for you. These are great for those who need just a little bit more support and are on a budget.


The 3-inch memory foam toppers are the most sought out size. The comfort level is near perfect if you are putting it on top of a firm mattress and it is great for taking pressure off of your joints and back. This one isn’t going to be as comfortable as buying a brand new memory foam mattress, but it will work if you are on a budget.


The 4-inch memory foam mattress topper is for people who may be over 250 pounds. This size mattress gives you the extra support you need and is also perfect for if you find yourself in a situation where you may need to sleep on the ground or a hard surface. I have the 4-inch and I absolutely love it, I couldn’t ask for a better mattress topper.

Top 5 Mattress Topper Reviews

Pinzon Basics Overfilled Ultra Soft Microplush Mattress Pad


  • 6.9 pounds
  • 20 x 20 x 9.2
  • Dry Clean Only

The Pinzon Basics is made from soft microplush fabric and has been overfilled for maximum comfort. It stuffed with 100% polyester filling and has an end-to-end box stitched mitered border. This prevents the fill from shifting around like the insides of a cheap comforter. One could say that sleeping on this pad is like sleeping on a cloud of fluff. It is designed for even distribution of the fill so that you aren’t finding yourself sleeping on one big lump of polyester fluff.

This pad has a 100% olefin bottom, 90% polyester/10% spandex sides and has deep pockets for ideal comfort. The best part is that it isn’t overly heavy, it only weighs around 7 pounds.

?You can buy this mattress pad as twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king. If you want something that is going to give you just a little more fluff on top of your bed, this is probably what you would be looking for.


  • Comfortable
  • Affordable
  • Deep pockets
  • Great quality
  • Easy to move around


  • Dry clean only
  • Not thick enough to notice a difference
  • Sinks in the middle
  • Slides around
  • Too warm

Sleep Innovations 4-Inch Dual Layer Queen Mattress Topper


  • 23.7 pounds
  • 80 X 60 X 4
  • Machine washable cover
  • 10-year limited warranty

The Sleep Innovations is 4-inches of heaven on a mattress. It forms to the curve of your body to help with pressure point relief and improve your circulation. The 2-layer design is made from a 2-inch down alternative layer and a 2-inch gel-infused memory foam layer. The down alternative layer has a stretch to fit cover that fits over the gel layer to secure it into place.

It is also machine washable and has a 300 thread count and has a 100 percent cotton fitted cover. This cover will hold the topper securely into place atop of your mattress.

With the Sleep Innovations 4-inch dual layer, you will get the feel of luxury without paying the price tag of luxury. It is perfect for those who may be looking for a topper that has the therapeutic support of an expensive mattress.?

With this topper, you will also find yourself sleeping in a much cooler environment. This topper has SureTemp technology which allows for airflow to keep your body temperature regulated for a better and more comfortable night of sleep.?


  • 10-year limited warranty
  • Good quality foam
  • Keeps you cool
  • Comfortable
  • Durable
  • Not too soft
  • Good quality foam


  • Shouldn’t use for 72 hours
  • Have to wait for it to fluff up
  • Heavy
  • Too soft
  • Chemical scent
  • No zipper on cover

Extra Plush Fitted Queen Mattress Topper


  • 8.8 pounds
  • 80 x 60
  • Machine Washable
  • 1-year hassle free warranty

This mattress topper is like one that you would find in the Marriot Hotels. It is perfect for adding a touch of comfort to your old and beat up mattress if you cannot afford a new one. It is also great for cooling down hot mattresses.

It's constructed from a 123 cotton blend cover that is stain and moisture resistant. Inside of the mattress is a cooling fill with advanced hypo-allergenic cluster down fiber. Each one of the pads is filled with a state-of-the-art fiberfill, called Revoloft, which is designed to deliver a luxurious feel. It also gives you the feeling of laying on goose down without all of the feathers sticking out and poking you.

The extra plush topper is made from 100% cotton and is anti-bunching. You won’t have to worry about the mattress topper bunching up and slipping off of the bottom mattress.

One of the best things about this topper is that it comes from a company that is veteran family owned and operated.?


  • 100% product satisfaction guaranteed
  • 100% refund or replacement
  • No questions asked returns
  • Fits deep mattress
  • Sides are clingy
  • No slipping
  • 100% cotton
  • Hypo-allergenic
  • Anti-bunching stitching
  • Made in the USA
  • Affordable


  • Does not cool as described
  • Falls apart after a year or so
  • Piling fabric
  • Fell apart in washer on hand wash setting
  • Flattened quickly

Density Visco Elastic Memory Foam Topper


  • 78 x 58 x 3
  • 28.8 pounds
  • Non-washable
  • 3-year limited warranty

The 3-inch thick elastic bed topper is a USA made product that is going to bring you a comfortable night of sleep. This mattress topper is meant to make your mattress more restful, comfortable and can support sagging areas of your mattress.

The topper forms to your body perfectly with a gel-like feel. It also helps to reduce pressure points that may cause you to toss and turn in night from pain or discomfort. It is made of all environmentally friendly processes and meets PURGeen certification standards.

With this mattress topper, you will be able to enjoy the benefits of a memory foam mattress with just the mattress topper and without spending a large amount of money. You will also not be subjected to any harmful toxic ingredients as you would with other mattresses. It may have a light foam smell that could linger for a couple of days to a few weeks, but it should not trigger any kind of allergies. It could bother some people if they have a sensitivity to smell, though. If it does bother you, the best thing to do is air out the room and wash the sheets after a few nights of sleeping on the mattress topper.?


  • 3-year limited warranty
  • Made in the USA
  • Comfortable
  • Fits bed end to end
  • 4 lb density
  • Thick foam


  • Slight chemical smell
  • Pricey
  •  No protective covering
  • Misleading
  • Too soft
  • Dips in the middle
  • No support
  • Does not fit right

Lucid Linenspa 2-inch Ventilated Memory Foam Mattress Topper


  • 30.7 x 22.8 x 0.8
  • 2.2 pounds
  • 3-year warranty
  • Non-washable

The Lucid Linenspa ventilated topper offers you a 2” of premium foam. It is ventilated to increase air flow that will help you sleep better at night at a comfortable temperature. It’s also made with open cell technology that prevents impressions from staying there forever.

This comfortable topper offers superior comfort and pressure relief. Not only that, but it creates a layer that is meant to help relieve neck, shoulder, and back pain because it cradles and supports the natural pressure points of your body. It also works through the night aligning your spine correctly and improving your posture while preventing lower back pain.

Along with comfort and posture support, it is also equipped with a resilient foam that makes for a more durable bed. It will not sink or bubble up as time goes on. If you are looking for a mattress topper that is not going to break your bank but give you excellent sleeping support, this mattress is the right choice. It may seem tiny, but once it puffs up, it adds support to your old, sagging mattress.


  • Affordable
  • 10 different sizes
  • 3-year warranty
  • Ventilated
  • Open cell technology
  • Superior comfort
  • Transforms beds to “like new”
  • Works well in RV’s


  • No back support
  • Not as dense as advertised
  • Lingering smell

The Winner

Mattress toppers are meant to help people sleep without spending hundreds or thousands of dollars on a high quality mattress. The clear winner of this battle is the Extra Plush Fitted Mattress Topper. The reasoning for this is because it has the most to offer with little disputes.

Yes, it may have a smell to it, but the directions do say to let it air out for a few days. It isn’t too expensive or too cheap. It is also the only one on the list that has a 100% refund or replacement and a 100% satisfaction guarantee and this is why it’s the best mattress topper.

Leave a Comment:

We believe in transparency, so please note we earn a commission on any sales generated through some of the links on our site at no additional cost to you.